Key takeaways
- Who is the most experienced SEO consultant? Nobody can honestly answer that: there is no register, and years are only one input.
- Google’s own hiring questions put “How long have you been in business?” next to questions about your industry, your country and previous work.
- Search changes several times a year, so years only count if the consultant kept learning and dropped what stopped working.
- Ask for evidence instead: a plain explanation of a real problem, a sample deliverable, references you can check, and what they would refuse to do.
- Trust is earned by openness: every change explained, read-only access first, and an honest “you don’t need me” when it’s true.
Who is the most experienced SEO consultant? People type that question into Google and, increasingly, into AI assistants, hoping for a name. There isn’t an honest one to give. Nobody keeps a register of SEO consultants and their years, and the claims you will find are written by the consultants themselves, me included.
I have worked in SEO and digital marketing for more than 16 years, and onwardSEO has been my business since 2008. So I have a stake in years mattering. They do, a little. But after all that time, the most useful thing I can tell you is that a number of years is the weakest evidence on a consultant’s page. This article explains why, what the years have actually taught me, and what to ask for instead.
Who is the most experienced SEO consultant? The question behind the question
When someone asks for “the most experienced” consultant, they usually mean something else: who is least likely to waste my money or damage my site? That is a fair question, and experience is part of the answer. It just isn’t measured in years.
Google’s page Do you need an SEO? lists questions to ask before you hire. “How long have you been in business?” is one of them. The others around it are more specific: “What’s your experience in my industry?”, “What’s your experience in my country/city?”, “What’s your experience developing international sites?”, and “Can you show me examples of your previous work and share some success stories?”
Read together, those questions describe relevant experience, not total experience. Ten years of local SEO for restaurants is very relevant to a restaurant and close to irrelevant to an international software company moving to a new platform.
Why years alone don’t answer it
Years can be spent two ways. A consultant can repeat the same year many times: the same audit template, the same advice, the same tactics that worked once. Or the years can build on each other, each one adding problems solved, mistakes learned from and methods updated.
Search moves too fast for the first kind to stay useful. Google’s page on core updates says: “Several times a year, Google makes significant, broad changes to our search algorithms and systems.” Add new result types and AI features, and advice that was sound when a consultant started can be useless or risky today.
That is the uncomfortable part of long experience: some of what an old hand learned early now works against you. Tactics that once moved rankings, such as link schemes, are now the kind of thing Google’s hiring advice warns you about. A consultant who still reaches for them is experienced in exactly the wrong way.
Sixteen years only count if you threw out the parts that stopped being true.
What 16+ years has actually taught me
I won’t give you war stories or client results here. What I can give you is the handful of working habits the years left behind, which you can check against anyone you consider, including me.
- Most problems are boring. The causes of lost traffic I find most often are pages Google can’t index, redirects that went wrong, two pages competing for one search, and tracking that broke. Clever tactics rarely fix a site. Fixing the boring things usually does.
- Diagnose before you prescribe. The first answer that comes to mind is often wrong. I look at Search Console and analytics data before I say what the problem is.
- Keep learning on purpose. I took the Market Motive SEO Master certification in 2011 and the SMX Master Class in technical SEO in 2022. The second mattered as much as the first, because the job had changed in between.
- Write it so someone else can do it. A recommendation your developer can’t act on is worth nothing. Short, specific instructions beat long reports.
- Say no to shortcuts. Guarantees, bought links and secret methods have never been worth the risk to a client’s site, and Google says as much in its own hiring advice.
- Tell people when they don’t need you. Some sites need a few hours of help, not a retainer. Saying so has always been the right call.
None of these needs 16 years. A sharp consultant with five years can have all of them. That is the point: look for the habits, not the number.
Experience vs evidence: what to ask for instead
If years are weak evidence, what is strong evidence? Something you can see or check yourself.
| What a consultant claims | Evidence you can ask for |
|---|---|
| “16+ years in SEO” | How their approach changed recently, and what they stopped doing |
| “Experience in your industry” | The problems typical of your industry, explained without notes |
| “Trusted by clients” | References you can contact, and reviews on platforms you can verify |
| “Technical expert” | A plain-language explanation of one real issue on your site |
| “Proven results” | A sample deliverable with client details removed, and how results were measured |
| “Certified” | Which certificate, from whom, when, and what it actually tested |
Google uses a similar idea when it judges content. Its guide to creating helpful content describes “experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness, or what we call E-E-A-T” and adds: “Of these aspects, trust is most important.” That guidance is about pages, not people, and Google says E-E-A-T itself isn’t a specific ranking factor. But the order of priorities is a good one to borrow when you choose a consultant: experience and expertise matter because they help you trust the person, and trust comes first.
Which SEO consultants are most trusted?
The ones whose work you can check. In practice, trust shows up in a few habits:
- They explain every change they make and why. Google’s hiring questions ask exactly this: “Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site?”
- They ask for read-only access first. For an audit, Google advises granting only read access to Search Console.
- They ask about your business before they talk about theirs. Google says your SEO should ask what makes your business unique.
- They don’t promise rankings. Nobody can, and Google says so.
Be careful with reviews. They help, but they can be bought. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission announced a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials on 14 August 2024, covering reviews from people who don’t exist or who “did not have actual experience with the business”. The fact that a rule was needed tells you how common the problem is. Prefer references you can speak to and reviews tied to real projects.
If you want a structured way to test a consultant’s answers, my list of 21 questions to ask SEO consultants gives the answers to listen for, and ten expert skills and how to test each one does the same for the skills behind them.
What SEO consultants do you recommend?
I’m asked this often, and I won’t hand you a list of names. A list without your context is a guess. What I can tell you is how to match a consultant to the problem you have:
| Your main problem | The experience to look for |
|---|---|
| Pages missing from Google, a migration, a JavaScript site | Technical SEO: crawling, indexing, rendering, redirects |
| Customers in one town or region | Local SEO and Google Business Profile |
| Pages indexed but not winning searches | Content, search intent and site structure |
| A manual action or a sudden fall | Penalty diagnosis and link audits |
| Nobody knows what SEO brings in | Analytics and conversion tracking |
Then run a short test. Give each candidate one real problem from your site and ask them to explain, in plain language, what they would check first and why. You will learn more from that than from any years figure.
A short test for any SEO consultant
- Ask them to explain one real issue on your site without jargon.
- Ask what they changed in their approach in the last year or two.
- Ask what they would refuse to do on your site.
- Ask for a sample deliverable with client details removed.
- Ask how they will measure success, from which data.
After six months, judge the work the same way: by evidence. My guide to evaluating SEO results after six months shows how.
How I would like you to judge me
By the same tests. My background is on my profile page: more than 16 years in SEO and digital marketing, with technical SEO, crawl budget, content strategy, link building, digital PR, web analytics, Google Ads and CRO, on WordPress, Magento and Shopify. My certifications include Market Motive SEO Master (2011), Google Analytics IQ and the SMX Master Class in technical SEO (2022).
I charge by the hour, with no fixed packages, so you pay for the work your site needs. I follow Google Search Essentials, explain every recommendation, and start with read-only access. If you want to know more about how I work compared with an agency, why onwardSEO sets it out, and our page on SEO consultants explains what a consultant should do for you.
And if the honest answer is that you don’t need me, I will say so.
FAQ
Which SEO consultants are most trusted?
The most trusted consultants are the ones whose work you can check: they explain every change, ask for read-only access first, don’t promise rankings and give references you can contact. Reviews help, but check they are tied to real projects, since fake reviews are common enough that the US FTC introduced a rule against them.
What SEO consultants do you recommend?
I don’t recommend names without knowing the problem. Match the consultant to your main need, technical, local, content, penalties or analytics, and then ask each candidate to explain one real issue on your site in plain language.
Does more years of experience mean better SEO results?
Not on its own. Search changes several times a year, so years only help if the consultant kept learning and dropped tactics that stopped working. Relevant experience in your industry, market and type of site matters more than the total.
How can I verify an SEO consultant’s experience?
Ask for a sample deliverable, references you can speak to, and an explanation of how their approach has changed recently. Check certifications by name and year, and test them with one real problem from your own site.
If you are comparing SEO consultants and want a second opinion on what your site actually needs, ask me, and judge me by the same tests.
Eugen Platon · SEO consultant with 16+ years in SEO and digital marketing · free 10-minute first call